Mahj Trainer / Learn / Dead hands

What is a dead hand in mahjong?

Last updated

A dead hand is a hand that can no longer legally win, usually because an exposure fits no hand on the card, the tile count is wrong, or its owner laid down a wrong mah jongg. The player stops drawing and discarding for the rest of that hand, but still pays whoever wins.

What makes a hand dead?

A hand dies when the table can see that it can never match a line on this year's card. The usual causes:

Who can call a hand dead?

Only another player can call a hand dead, and only when the tiles on the table prove it. Nobody calls their own hand dead. The usual way is to point at the exposure or the discards and say why no card line can work. If the player accepts it, the hand is dead. If they dispute it, play goes on and the table checks the card when the hand ends.

A wrong claim has a cost. Depending on the rules in use, the accuser pays the wrongly accused player a penalty or loses their own hand, so be sure first.

What does a dead player do?

A dead player sits out the rest of the hand and keeps their tiles where they are.

Can you take jokers from a dead hand?

Yes, from its correct exposures. A joker in a group that was legal before the hand died stays available to any player who holds the real tile, on their own turn. The exposure that caused the death is different: it goes back to the owner's rack, joker included, so nobody can take that joker.

Where tables play it differently

A worked example

North calls East's 6 Dot and exposes a pung with a joker in it:

6D6DJJK

North forgets to discard, and East, next in turn, draws. North now holds 14 tiles when it is not North's turn. West points it out, everyone counts, and North's hand is dead. North stops playing.

The pung itself was legal, so its joker is still live. On West's next turn, West hands over a 6 Dot and takes the joker. When South wins three turns later, North pays South the same as East and West.

Common questions

Should you call someone's hand dead in mahjong?

Yes, when you are sure and the tiles on the table prove it. Calling it stops a hand that cannot win from drawing, discarding or calling, which keeps the hand fair. Be certain first: a wrong claim carries a penalty.

Can you call your own hand dead?

No. Only another player can call a hand dead. If you know your hand cannot win, keep drawing and discarding until someone calls it, and throw safe tiles so you do not feed a winner.

Does a dead hand still pay?

Yes. A dead hand pays the winner the full amount, the same as the other players who did not win. If nobody wins before the wall runs out, nobody pays.

Is a dead hand out for the whole game?

No. A hand is dead only for the hand being played. The player is dealt in as normal for the next hand.

Can a dead hand call a discard?

No. A dead player stops drawing, discarding and calling, so every discard goes to the live players.